08 January 2009

needs vs. desires

Recently I used the phrase "your personal needs and desires" in a speech about how to find a romantic partner. I think that those two innocent-looking words do indeed touch on a very profound subject in dating on which I want to elaborate in this post.
First of all there is a great divide in that a person's needs can be understood to mean all the things necessary to make that person happy, while her desires are the things she is striving for, admiring, because she thinks that they will make her happy.
People always want to be inspired, have high goals, find something of special value. May it be somebody really good looking, or somebody really social, or somebody really successful in his life projects (career or hobbies). That's something we look up to, or desire.
Now, unfortunately what we think we need and what we really need are often very different. Sometimes it can even be opposites and we make ourselves unhappy until we realize it. Or sometimes, our needs encompass things which we never really thought about and don't know how important they are.

We form desires when we grow up, but we find out about our needs when we grow old. Those people who learn about their needs before they grow old, will have the power to make themselves truly happy.

But apart from the know/don't-know divide, there's another dichotomy which is described by needs vs. desires. This dichotomy is about two poles of attraction which both have to be strong in order for a person to fall in love. The desires are what makes their opposite noteworthy, admirable, valuable, desireable, they focus on success, talents, strenghts, looks, money, brains, things that the person offers to you, while the needs on the other hand are a counterbalance are about things that refer more to you than your opposite: will the person give you comfort when you need it, will they respect you, will you be important to them, are you even good enough for them?
Our desires spur us on to date out of our league, while the needs will remind us to be realistic and look for people who are just good to us.
A person that only represents our desires would be considered way out of their league by most and they would never try to ask them out or would be quite suspicious about serious intentions when asked out by them. A person that mostly represents our needs, however, would be considered as just a friend by most people and they would say that there's just "something" lacking to make the relationship a romantic one.
I think there is much more to say about this, since many aspects of dating can be explained by it. Let's leave that for later posts.


This post is dedicated to L., S., and Y. for the inspiration and to K. for the encouragement.

Labels:

2 Comments:

At 13 January, 2009 21:18 , Blogger Doug Mounce said...

Saw your link to John Sidles. He's a man of wisdom.

On this post, however, you might consider what Rene Girard says about needs and desire.

 
At 14 January, 2009 11:02 , Blogger Robert Jack Wild said...

Doug, thanks for the link.
On Rene Girard's long Wikipedia entry the first page already mentions his invention "mimetic desire": imitation is an aspect of behaviour that not only affects learning but also desire, and imitated desire is a cause of conflict
I instantly liked this idea, I was often thinking the same, but never dared to state it so strongly.
Indeed, if "desire" denotes what we think we need, then our thinking can be just plain wrong and we might desire things that are actually very bad for us and dissatisfying our needs.
Humans learn most of the social rules by imitation and I think desire is no different. We are looking for people who are like us for ideas what might make us happy. Unfortunately, since the human nature is not yet well understood we are often imitating people who are superficially like us, e.g. members of the same social class, people with similar education, similar interests. This is often fallacious. Instead we should look for people who have a similar personality, share the similar values. Those people are likely to have similar needs to ours and our desire will be less likely to mislead us when we imitate our soul mates.
Unfortunately the concept of personality and fundamentally different characters is not very well-know and well-founded in our society and popular culture; not even really in the science of human behaviour (i.e. psychology).
Humanity still has a long way to go, before our society knows how to make people happy!

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home